Reasoning between Rules and Discretion: A Comparative Study of the Normative Platform for Best Interest Decision-Making on Adoption in England and Norway
نویسندگان
چکیده
Abstract This article examines discretionary reasoning in child’s best interest (CBI) assessments two jurisdictions, England and Norway, decision concerning adoption from care. The countries’ systems differ child protection orientations levels of autonomy but share the legal moral yardstick CBI. Judgments Family Court (n = 29) County Social Welfare Board Norway are analysed through a qualitative content analysis, following logics practical reasoning. analysis provided rich detailed testimony how CBI decisions were justified reveal that similar normative platform was guiding across countries. There were, however, differences within between countries terms application justifications norms, some which likely to be connected different interpretations others systemic constructions structures. Moreover, having more legislative guidance may have contributed explicit deliberative although it does not appear ensure consistent or predictable as inconsistencies variation found both contexts. However, while Norwegian judges’ deliberation less ‘balanced’, applied manner judgements. Although this contributes consistency predictability, use non-democratically constituted ‘rules’ decision-making poses challenge for legitimate decision-making.
منابع مشابه
a comparative study of the relationship between self-, peer-, and teacher-assessments in productive skills
تمایل به ارزیابی جایگزین و تعویض آن با آزمون سنتی مداد و کاغذ در سالهای اخیر افزایش یافته است. اکثر زبان آموزان در کلاس های زبان از نمره نهایی که استاد تعیین میکند ناراضی اند. این تحقیق جهت بررسی ارزیابی در کلاس های زبان انگلیسی به هدف رضایتمندی زبان آموزان از نمره هایشان انجام گرفته است که در آن نمرات ارائه شده توسط سه گروه ارزیاب (ارزیابی خود دانشجو، همسالان واستاد) در مهارت های تولید (تکل...
15 صفحه اولa study on rate making and required reserves determination in reinsurance market: a simulation
reinsurance is widely recognized as an important instrument in the capital management of an insurance company as well as its risk management tool. this thesis is intended to determine premium rates for different types of reinsurance policies. also, given the fact that the reinsurance coverage of every company depends upon its reserves, so different types of reserves and the method of their calc...
a comparative study of the theme of "marriage" in three victorian novelists: charles dickens, george eliot and thomas hardy
این تحقیق کوشیده است با انتخاب پنج رمان از میان آثار برگزیده، «چارلز دیکنز»، «جورج الیوت» و «توماس هاردی » و با رویکردی تطبیقی به بررسی درونمایه ی «ازدواج» در آثار این سه رمان نویس بزرگ دوره ی ویکتوریا بپردازد. فرضیه ی اولیه ی تحقیق این بوده است که چارلز دیکنز (1870- 1812) با زبانی شوخ و گزنده، جورج الیوت(1880- 1819) با نگاهی آموزشی–اندرزگونه و توماس هاردی(1928- 1840) با رویکردی تلخ وانتقادی به...
the investigation of the relationship between type a and type b personalities and quality of translation
چکیده ندارد.
the relation between bilingualism and translation: a case study of turkish bilingual and persian monolingual translation students
translation studies have become an accepted academic subject and books, journals and doctoral dissertations appear faster than one can read them all (bassnet and lefevere, 1990). but this field also brought with itself so many other issues which needed to be investigated more, in the heart of which, issues like ideology, ethics, culture, bilingualism and multilingualism. it is reported that ove...
ذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
ژورنال
عنوان ژورنال: International Journal of Law, Policy and The Family
سال: 2021
ISSN: ['1464-3707', '1360-9939']
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/lawfam/ebab036